Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint Review

Milabu Rating

  • Overall
    (4.4)
  • Performance
    (4.9)

Price Category: Value

  • $17.99 Retail

Sign up for a discount

88 sign ups needed for 10% off
Learn more


Pros

  • Easy to blend
  • Buildable light to medium coverage
  • Blurs pores
  • Long wearing

Cons

  • Dropper has too much excess product
  • Packaging gets dirty easily
  • Shade undertones could be better

Maybelline Skin Tint – Quick Review

At the end of the review Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint has a foolproof application, skin-like finish, and incredible long wear.

Video Makeup Tutorial & Wear Test

ft. Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint

Sign up for a discount

88 sign ups needed for 10% off
Learn more

Some links to purchase are affiliate.

The new Maybelline skin tint has big shoes to fill – let’s review it.

Let’s welcome the newest member of the loved Maybelline Super Stay family: Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint. Personally, I love skin tints for their natural, skin-like appearance and lightweight feel. They’re the perfect summer face base! This product has big shoes to fill, joining several other top performing skin tints already on the market. Let’s see where Maybelline lands.

Quick Rating Rundown

This Product

(4.4)
Maybelline Super Stay 24H Skin Tint

:Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint

Price: $17.99

1.0 oz

Value

(3.8)

Application

(5)

Coverage

(4.8)

Texture

(4.8)

Longevity

(5)

Shade Range

(4.8)

Extra Benefits

(2.9)

Buy now

Industry Standard

(4.2)
L'oreal True Match Nude Tinted Serum

:L’Oréal True Match Nude Hyaluronic Tinted Serum

Price: $19.99

1.0 oz

Value

(3.7)

Application

(4.9)

Coverage

(4.4)

Texture

(4.6)

Longevity

(4.5)

Shade Range

(4.4)

Extra Benefits

(2.9)

Buy now

MILABU PICKS

(4.5+)
Top Skin Tints

:Best Skin Tints For Everyday Makeup

Price: $7 – $50

various sizes

Value

(4.5+)

Application

(4.5+)

Coverage

(4.5+)

Texture

(4.5+)

Longevity

(4.5+)

Shade Range

(4.5+)

Extra Benefits

(4.5+)

Buy now

Our Rating Criteria

What is a skin tint?

Step aside, full coverage foundations, let’s go from heavy weight to lightweight. Skin tints have taken the beauty community by storm, offering a lightweight, barely-there makeup look. What sets them apart is their ability to provide more than just some coverage. In fact, skin tints often come packed with additional skincare benefits, making them a coveted item for those seeking a minimalistic approach to beauty.

Now, let’s delve into what exactly constitutes a skin tint. You may already be familiar with terms like “tinted moisturizer,” “BB cream,” and “CC cream,” all of which fall under the skin tint umbrella. In our view, a skin tint is a face base that offers sheer to medium coverage, effortlessly camouflaging imperfections, evening out the skin tone, and providing a sensation as if you’re wearing nothing at all. Typically, these products have a shorter wear time, usually lasting around 6-8 hours.

Now, back to the rest of the Maybelline Skin Tint review.

Promises vs. Performance: Will the Maybelline Skin Tint hold its own?

Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint promises up to 24 hours of wear with. its sweat, humidity, and fade resistant formula. It provides light to medium coverage with a natural, radiant skin-like finish. The lightweight formula is infused with Vitamin C to brighten the complexion and deliver skincare benefits with each wear.

My Review Thoughts – Maybelline Skin Tint

Easy application, buildable coverage, pore blurring, and long wearing? There’s not much I can ask for from a skin tint! And, luckily the Maybelline skin tint checks all these boxes and more. Let’s start with the foolproof application. Whether you use a brush, sponge, or your fingers, it applies easily and the coverage builds easily. You can get anywhere from a light to medium coverage that hides imperfections without settling into pores and lines, or clinging to texture. It gives a beautiful, soft focus blurred effect on skin.

Even better, Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint is long wearing. While I haven’t tested its full 24 hour claims, I’m happy to report it has an incredible wear for a a skin tint. I find it lasts a solid 6 hours on my skin before it starts breaking apart or my oils start peeking through, but even past that it still looks really good.

Maybelline Skin Tint Application

Maybelline Skin Tint Swatch
Maybelline Skin Tint Application: before and after (right)

How It Compares: Is this the best drugstore skin tint?

Based on its ratings, Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint may just be the best at the drugstore. The application is foolproof. It gives light to medium coverage while remaining weightless and skin-like. The finish can be described as natural, healthy radiance. It blurs pores, smooths lines, and doesn’t accentuate any texture on skin. And, finally, it has one of the best skin tint longevities I’ve come across.

What can be improved? It’s packaging does get dirty easily, and the shade undertones could be a bit better. But, overall, this Maybelline skin tint holds its own as a top performer. Check out the chart below where I compare Maybelline vs L’oreal skin tint, and I add one of my favorites clean versions – Summer Fridays Sheer Skin Tint.

Comparison To Top Skin Tints

Industry Standard – Drugstore Skin Tint

My favorite drugstore skin tint would have to be L’Oreal True Match Hyaluronic Tinted Serum. This one gives a light coverage with a radiant finish (more natural looking). It has a satin, non-greasy feel and lightweight wear. The texture is thinner, which, in my opinion, allows it to pair even better with a wide variety of products. It creates a stunning blurred effect on the skin, doesn’t accentuate imperfections, and doesn’t contribute to excess oiliness. And these are just a few of the reasons why I love this skin tint.

But, when it comes to coverage and longevity, there are not many skin tints that can compare to Maybelline super stay. It delivers! Further, as good as L’oreal skin tint looks on the skin, after the review I was surprised that Maybelline looked slightly better.

This makes Maybelline Skit Tint the new standard for skin tint in drugstore category.

Best Clean Skin Tint

Skin-like, undetectable, and skincare-infused are the best words to describe the Summer Fridays Skin Tint. Simply put, it’s stunning on and has great benefits for the skin. It provides a more even complexion, diminishing redness, pores, and discoloration. The Summer Fridays Skin Tint is the best clean skin tint on the market.

However, it does not deliver in when it comes to pigment or longevity. It is made to be shear. And when it comes to longevity I’m not sure there is a skin tint that can outperform Maybelline at this time.

Best Value Skin Tint
Wet n Wild Tinted Hydrator Reviews

In a side-by-side comparison with the Maybelline Skin Tint, the Wet n Wild Tinted Hydrator distinguishes itself mainly through its budget-friendly price point. For those who are conscious of their spending but don’t want to compromise on quality, this product emerges as an attractive option. The Wet n Wild Tinted Hydrator leans more towards providing a matte finish, which is great for those with oily skin, helping to control shine and maintain a balanced complexion. However, when it comes to the more nuanced skincare benefits, particularly hydration and evening out skin tone, it doesn’t quite match up to the capabilities offered by the other skin tints like Maybelline, Revlon, and L’oreal.

Performance Rating and Comparison

This Product

(4.9)
Maybelline Super Stay 24H Skin Tint

:Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint

Application

(5)

Coverage (med)

(4.8)

Texture

(4.8)

Longevity

(5)

Industry Standard

(4.6)
L'oreal True Match Nude Tinted Serum

:L’Oréal True Match Nude Hyaluronic Tinted Serum

Application

(4.9)

Coverage (light)

(4.4)

Texture

(4.6)

Longevity

(4.5)

Shade Range

(4.4)

Best Clean

(4.8)
Summer Fridays Sheer Skin Tint

:Summer Fridays Sheer Skin Tint

Price: $42.00

Application

(5)

Coverage (shear)

(4.8)

Texture

(4.9)

Longevity

(4.5)

Our Rating Criteria

Advertised Product Highlights

Maybelline Super Stay 24HR Skin Tint

# of SHADES: 18

FORMULATION: Liquid

FINISH: Natural, radiant

COVERAGE: Light to medium

LONGEVITY: 24 hours

SKIN TYPE: All skin types, including sensitive

PROTECTION: No SPF

BENEFITS: Contains vitamin C; Brightens skin; Sweat, humidity, and fade resistant

CLEAN BEAUTY CLAIMS: Vegan; Dermatologist tested; Non comedogenic 

Edited by Maddie

Back to top